The Holiday Spirit

My son and I dared to challenge the hordes at the mall on this Black Friday. We went to a local stop in Sherman Oaks that I knew would be crowded, but not oppressive. I had a couple of items that I wanted to check on, but did not need to do any real shopping.

While I was waltzing through the mall we encountered numerous examples of what I dislike about the holiday season.

Frankly as a Jewish person I find the crush of Christmas music/decorations to be rather oppressive. The commercial aspect just drowns out any religious compoent, or so it seems to me. If that holiday was a part of my faith I would be offended at the influence of money upon the holiday.

And to that end I really dislike any attempt to equate Chanukah as being the Jewish version of Christmas. They are not equivalent and shouldn't be drawn that way.

I also have a problem with the push to be nicer and more charitable because it is part of the holiday spirit. What it says to me is that it is only important to act like this for about 45 days a year. In other words members of the disenfranchised groups only have a small window in which it is meaningful to demonstrate concern about their welfare.

It is the same perverse logic surrounding Valentine's day, which is in large part why I refuse to observe the day. You can expect commentary about that false holiday closer to mid-February.

The bottom line to me is that it is wrong and disingenuous to suggest that we should be better people for a short time each year. The ideals that we see people preach during this time of year are things that should be expressed with the same fervor all year long.


foxymama said...

See, this is why I enjoy reading your blog. It always amazes me that you so ably express the thoughts and feelings which have been rattling around in my own head and heart. Over and over again you do this... Amazing! A little bit scary... ~;^)

wanda said...

Jack, Jack, Jack, I can see your blog is going to be on my 'I have got to read more of what this guy has to say' list. I found you via Brian, whom I found via Sally whom I found via Brenda.
Can I tell you just how much I share your sentiment regarding Christmas? Do I even need to? It is through blogging and reading how many others share my feelings that I can now manage not to crawl into bed and stay there until January 2nd.

Jack Steiner said...

I just write about what I am thinking about and this is what happens. Thanks, I do appreciate the kind words.

Pallywood Posts

 I think a bunch of the posts about Pallywood that have been written and or linked here have to be updated. Probably a bunch of bad links, k...